Why rising energy costs won’t drive everyone back to the office
Why Rising Energy Costs Won't Fuel a Return to the Office
October 5, 2022
October 5, 2022

By Lisa Gallagher, co-founder and director of Flexibility Works

Rising energy costs will certainly be a challenge this winter, whether you’re an employer or someone paying the bills for your home. But we don’t share the view that home working is under threat as a result.

The energy comparison site Uswitch said recently that people who spent less than £30 a week commuting would be better off working in the office, rather than paying an estimated £131 to £209 a month in additional energy costs to work from home.

We shared our view with The Times this week that these figures played nicely into the hands of work traditionalists, who still want everyone back in the office full-time, and used the media story to sound the death knell for home working.

But alongside some dubious financial calculations, Uswitch and the traditionalists missed the bigger picture – home working has huge benefits beyond money that people won’t readily give up, and home working might be needed to help businesses cut their own costs this winter.

True costs

On the finance front, Uswitch unrealistically assumed home workers would have their heating on 24/7 in the winter. A fact check article by Channel 4 suggested a more modest increase of £50 a month. And this was before the introduction of the Government’s new – lower – price cap. Uswitch also failed to take into account other costs savings, such as making lunch rather than buying it, or not needing so much childcare.

Benefits

But the value in working from home is not just about money. Being able to do school drop-offs and pick-ups, walk your dog, go for a run at lunchtime, nip out for a doctor’s appointment or put a wash on makes life easier, less stressful. Just better.

According to the ONS, 84% of people who had to work from home during the pandemic planned a mix of home and office working in future. While our own data from 1,000 Scottish desk-based workers this summer showed almost three quarters felt home or hybrid working delivered the best work life balance.

Some people, particularly those on lower incomes, will have to make difficult decisions this winter about where they can afford to work. And, of course, not all jobs can be done from home.

But we anticipate that many people will find the financial and other benefits of home working still outweigh those from working in the office.

Options for employers

And let’s not forget that businesses are also facing drastic bill increases. It may suit them to have fewer people in the office. Employers could reduce how long an office is open each day, heat fewer floors, or specify a day when the office will be closed. The fact people can work from home gives employers options – options that frontline organisations and their workers don’t have.

This will be a difficult winter for people and for businesses. Home workers need to think carefully about what’s going to work best for them. Employers need to do the same. Both sides will need to talk. But whatever the challenges, home working is here to stay.

Related blog posts

How hybrid working is getting cyclists back in the saddle

How hybrid working is getting cyclists back in the saddle

By Jenny Legg, Head of Communications at Flexibility Works We delivered free hybrid training to six Scottish employers in 2023, and we’re delighted with the positive feedback on how our sessions have helped teams work more effectively. But we’re also wheelie pleased...

read more
Scotland 4-Day Working Week

Scotland 4-Day Working Week

Phil McParlane, founder of jobs site 4dayweek.io guest blogs for us about the possibilities around a four-day work week. In recent years, the idea of a four-day work week has gained widespread appeal. For instance, in September 2023, the Scottish Government announced...

read more
Your hybrid questions answered

Your hybrid questions answered

It was great to see so many people at our hybrid working event this month. We shared some of our new research findings on what hybrid working really looks like in Scotland, and heard from two employers on their approaches to hybrid. If you were there, you’ll know we...

read more